Updated · ToyCue Editorial Team

How to choose male sex toys

A step-by-step way to compare male sex toy brands on price, free shipping, materials, discreet billing and returns, using Blush and UndercoverCondoms as worked examples.

Two different kinds of seller

Start by working out what each brand actually is. UndercoverCondoms is a retailer rather than a workshop of its own. Alongside lube and condom it carries toys in vibrator, rabbit and g spot, and its featured items come from several outside makers: a rechargeable silicone plug, a strapless silicone dildo, a couples set built around a harness, and a machine. Blush is the opposite kind of seller: a house brand that designs its own devices, states one feature set for them, and has been doing so since 2007.

That difference changes what a price comparison can tell you. A retailer mixes budget stock with higher priced gear, so the smallest number on the page says little about the rest of the shelf. A house brand applies the same specification sheet across the range, so one check on materials or water resistance carries much further. Read both in the male sex toys rankings, then open the UndercoverCondoms review and the Blush review next to each other and compare them line by line.

Price, and what arrives at no extra cost

UndercoverCondoms lists prices of $1.95, so the entry point is low. Blush offers a different kind of saving: its free shipping threshold is $0, so delivery adds nothing to the basket. A shopper buying one item should weigh a low sticker price against a free delivery, and a shopper buying several should watch what a retailer adds at checkout, since a low listed price is not the whole cost.

Range width matters as much as the entry price. UndercoverCondoms covers vibrator, rabbit and g spot in one catalogue, while Blush’s range is narrower and built around its own devices. Put the items you would really buy into a basket on each site and read the total rather than comparing the smallest figure on the page.

Whose name appears on the statement

Both sellers ship discreetly, and both bill under a company name rather than a product name. UndercoverCondoms says statements show only ‘CBUS Ecommerce Group, LLC’, and its legal entity is CBUS Ecommerce Group, LLC. Blush says Statements on orders are billed from SEV ENTERPRISE INC., with a legal entity of SEV ENTERPRISE INC.

Both are headquartered in the United States and US. Where they part company is reach. UndercoverCondoms ships to the United States and Canada, while Blush ships to US, so anyone outside those markets has no listed route and should settle the question before building a basket.

Materials and the claims attached to them

Blush lists platinum silicone and tpe across its range, against silicone for UndercoverCondoms. Both describe their material as phthalate free nonporous in identical terms. Read that as a statement about the surface and what it excludes, not as a test result.

Lubricants are where the wording overlaps. Both list a water base, water for Blush and water for UndercoverCondoms, and both describe their lube as formulated without glycerin or parabens and as safe with condoms. UndercoverCondoms goes a step further and marks its lube as safe to use with toys. A body-safe or toy-safe label is a manufacturer’s statement to read on the product page, so check whether it covers the whole device or only the part that touches skin.

For two devices on the same shelf the practical questions are identical: what the material is, how wide the safety statement is, and whether the lube you already use is compatible with it.

Water resistance, power and runtime

Water protection is where the two listings differ most. Blush states IPX7 as its standard, covering the rabbit vibrator at the top of its own range. UndercoverCondoms gives water-resistant (no IPX stated) for the rechargeable silicone plug it features, with a stated runtime of 60 minutes.

A rating written in full tells you the standard. A line that stops at water resistance leaves the deeper question open, so plan to rinse under a tap rather than submerge. Runtime figures are normally quoted at the lowest setting, which makes 60 minutes a floor rather than a promise. On charging, read the connector on each listing: one Blush wand bundle arrives in a box with a charging case and a remote, and the brand’s listed feature is a network.

Rechargeable is listed for the UndercoverCondoms plug, while a retailer’s category page can mix rechargeable and battery models together. Check the power source on each listing before you compare two devices on price alone.

Returns, and who answers the question

UndercoverCondoms publishes a returns policy listed as satisfaction guarantee with a money-back window of 30 days. Blush sets out its shipping terms rather than a return window, so ask for the return terms in writing before ordering a multi-piece set you might want to send back.

Support runs through email and help centre at UndercoverCondoms, which means a question about sizing, batteries or a return can reach a person. Put the question to a specific listing rather than to the range in general. Retailer staff field more questions on a given product than a house brand does, so the answer tends to be more detailed.

Reading the rankings with the same columns

Take the columns in one order every time: price, then what is free, then materials, then discreet billing, then returns. Apply that order to every brand in the male sex toys rankings, and open the EIS review, the Screaming O review and the PlusOne review with the same checklist beside you.

Where a brand leaves a field out, treat it as an open question rather than a pass mark. A retailer that lists water resistance without a full rating and a house brand that states a full rating are answering different amounts of the same question, and the gap between them is the useful part of the comparison.

See the full ranking: Top male sex toys compared →

Sources